Dead Hackers Society
Other BBSes »
 
 
Demoscene   Coding   CT60   Buy/sell

Atari demoscene BBS
 
Re: Arts 060 intro
Posted by: evil Jul,16.2005-15:31 

> 3) hard criticism is more constructive for the future and for us than use all the time: good work, nice intro, yeah or any sweet words...

Then we function completely different. Nobody asked to sweet-butter anything. Perhaps we read the word "lame" in totally different ways. I've been around since the 80's, and that word has always been user to describe the lowest-piece of crap imaginable.

Critism as "could have been faster, longer, have better music or better design" could actually HELP improvements, and you're able to encourage further developments as well. To just say that something totally suck can't possibly be constructive critisism.

An example, I am no major fan of the Chosneck interface (looks pretty, works crappy). Would grey even had considered to continue the mag if he got a dozen comments that what he does is nothing but lame and that chosneck is shit? I think not.

And as an ending, have you ever wondered why no polish demo crew is still here doing demos (nothing since year 2000 if I am right) ? If they hear these kind of comments day in and out, it's no wonder they quit..

--
Anders Eriksson
ae@dhs.nu








[All messages in this thread]    [Start new thread]

Topic Posted by  Date 
Arts 060 intro MacFalcon Jul,15.2005-09:34
  Re: Arts 060 intro deez Jul,15.2005-10:54
    Re: Arts 060 intro mOOnie Jul,15.2005-11:37
      Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,15.2005-12:38
        Re: Arts 060 intro ray Jul,15.2005-13:03
          Re: Arts 060 intro mOOnie Jul,15.2005-13:36
        Re: Arts 060 intro earx Jul,15.2005-13:52
          Re: Arts 060 intro sqward Jul,15.2005-16:19
          Re: Arts 060 intro sqward Jul,15.2005-16:22
            Re: Arts 060 intro gwem Jul,15.2005-17:46
            Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,15.2005-18:05
              Re: Arts 060 intro havoc Jul,15.2005-19:27
                Re: Arts 060 intro gwem Jul,15.2005-21:47
                Re: Arts 060 intro gwem Jul,15.2005-21:53
            Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,16.2005-10:24
              Re: Arts 060 intro Vido Jul,16.2005-10:33
                Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,16.2005-13:06
                  Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,16.2005-13:11
                    Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,16.2005-13:12
                  Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,16.2005-13:22
                    Re: Arts 060 intro mOOnie Jul,16.2005-14:17
                      Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,16.2005-14:52
                      Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,16.2005-15:31
                        Re: Arts 060 intro mOOnie Jul,16.2005-17:21
                          Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,16.2005-17:32
                        Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,17.2005-19:31
                          Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,17.2005-21:19
                            Re: Arts 060 intro Grey Jul,17.2005-21:33
                              Re: Arts 060 intro evil Jul,17.2005-21:55
                  Re: Arts 060 intro havoc Jul,16.2005-13:56
                    End of story aRt Jul,16.2005-18:18
                      Re: End of story ZWF/Paradox Jul,16.2005-19:09
                        Go on, just one more! CiH Jul,19.2005-11:52
                          Re: Go on, just one more! Grey Jul,19.2005-13:48
                            Re: Go on, just one more! CiH Jul,19.2005-14:06
                              Re: Go on, just one more! ZWF/Paradox Jul,19.2005-18:25
                              Re: Go on, just one more! CiH Jul,19.2005-19:39


Reply to this message
Name:
Topic:
Anti-troll code:

Message:

What's the anti-troll code?
That's your personal code to be able to add comments and messages on the dhs.nu site.
Don't have a code or forgot it? Fix it here.
© 1994-2025 Dead Hackers Society Contact: Anders Eriksson